I mean the true ending, post lord of doors, so if you don't want to be spoiled, stop reading. . Sign up to receive information regarding NS events, subscription offers & product updates. Reviewed in the United States on May 15, 2013. If 2001s The Constant Gardener was le Carrs attack on Big Pharma, A Delicate Truth is an attack on what he calls Big Greed the transformation of a market economy into a market society. Afterwards, everyone involved was taken to Crete and were either brainwashed or paid off to believe that the operation had actually been successful. But, after the disappointingly sketchy Our Kind of Traitor (2011), which relied too heavily on hectic narration, the 81-year-old Le Carr is back at full power with a book that draws on a career's worth of literary skill and international analysis. Set in 2008 and 2011, the book features a British/American covert mission in Gibraltar and the subsequent consequences for two British civil servants. Reviewed in the United States on March 7, 2014. The shadowy web of government and corporations in the war on terror, Reviewed in the United States on June 5, 2014. The New Statesmans global affairs newsletter, every Monday and Friday. His contact warns him that a series of red flags are attached to the information, and that he should be careful. John le Carre began writing spy novels while he was working for the British intelligence agencies MI5 and MI6. In 2008, Toby Bell, the Private Secretary to junior Foreign Office minister Fergus Quinn, becomes suspicious of his superior's behavior following a meeting with businessman Jay Crispinfounder of the private security firm Ethical Outcomesand the company's financier, Miss Maisie, an independently wealthy, Islamophobic American evangelical. Over the past decade or so, his books have increasingly focused on the moral vacuum that has emerged from the hollow triumph of capitalism, as we all discover that there is nothing free about a world in which anything is potentially for sale on the contrary, it is proving very costly indeed. The name is presumably a deeply ironic reference to Henry Vs St Crispins Day speech, for this Crispin is busily selling arms, honour and country to the highest bidder. He desperately tries to make contact with Oakley and seek advice as to what he should do with the tape. As we all know, Blair was harboring a huge secret from her husband that could break their union irrevocably. Hustled into identifying with a decent chap in an unpleasant spot (with a bed big enough for six), the reader has little time to wonder what very British features look like and how they can be deemed honourable on sight while being simultaneously engorged with rage. This prologue neatly combines the location of a notorious incident from the Thatcher years (when, in 1988, three IRA operatives were shot by the SAS on the Rock) withthe target and techniques of theUS-UK war on terror. None of the police officers who responded to the original 911 call on the night of February 23 questioned Paul in front of their car dashcams, as they were possibly scared of tainting the . Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. Jeb, Paul, and the team track Aladdin's arrival on Gibraltar and his progression towards the safe house. A Delicate Truth, like most of le Carrs recent novels, feels like a rebuttal to George Smileys theory. Along the bumpy way we discover that governments are themselves governed these days by outside pressures, as sinister as they are what else? Then along came Iraq and the "war on terror". Lying can and does clearly serve a devious social purpose. Sensing trouble, he activates the recording device on his desk and leaves. It is no surprise when our hero, Toby, a Foreign Office up-and-comer who can play the toff but is state-educated and sprung from pious artisan parents, is informed by his long-time mentor, a diplomat of impeccable public-spiritedness, whose private pleasures are of the kind attached to Englishmen by our Gallic neighbours, that this friend of the Tea Party, scourge of Islam, homosexuals, abortion and, I believe, contraception [is] currently residing in Lowndes Square, London SW. One entire side of it!. New Labour loves Big Greed, and Big Greed has armies of amoral lawyers and accountants on the make and pays them the earth to make rings round us. The novel may be loosely based on Operation Flavius, the 1988 operation during which three members of the Provisional IRA were shot dead by the British SAS in Gibraltar. Once he realizes his minister is hiding something important from him, he begins to dig until he uncovers some of the machinations and personal interplay that are leading inexorably to Operation Wildlife. He asks Toby to stay alert and to notify him if he hears or notices anything else. It is exquisitely narrated, in two time frames that slowly merge. Kit is soon revealed to be the Paul' who represented Minister Quinn during Wildlife. The next day, Toby meets with Shorty in a caf. They arrange an interview in London later in the week. I have a theory which I suspect is rather immoral, George Smiley said in John le Carrs 1974 classic, Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy. Each of us has only a quantum of compassion. As Paulacting as a neutral liaison between English and American intelligenceobserves from a blind, a strike team lays siege to the house. Bell further reconnects with Giles Oakley, now a private banker, for advice; Bell learns that a guilt-stricken Oakley has suffered a nervous breakdown and the two part ways after Oakley makes awkward sexual overtures towards Bell. Eventually, Probyn learns that he was unwitting in more ways than one: told that the top-secret operation had been an unqualified success, he was shipped off to a plum post in the Caribbean and knighted, when, in reality, the operation unethical on the face of it was far more immoral than he knew and a fiasco to boot. A Delicate Truth is based around a fictious Operation Wildlife, a top-secret mission in Gibraltar, involving private spy companies . 4) 'Spare' by Prince Harry - Book Review. Toby is the idealist in the room, for he wishes to make a difference or, as he had put it a little shamefacedly to his examiners, take part in his countrys discovery of its true identity in a post-imperial, post-cold-war world. A friend from the Treasury gives him and us a reminder of what this new world looks like: Were clever and nice, but were understaffed and underpaid and we want the best for our country, which is old-fashioned of us. As the questions mount, so does the suspense: what really happened on the night of Operation Wildlife? Le Carr sees Toby Bell as "the thirty-something rising star of Her Majesty's Foreign Service the striving ambitious fellow I fancy myself to have been at much the same age" whereas Sir Christopher ("Kit") Probyn is "a retired Foreign Office civil servant, who lives in rural Cornwall" the author "lived in a clifftop house outside St Buryan, near Land's End, for more than 40 years". As readers, we have to be on our mettle, but we also know we'll be well cared for by a silver-haired major-domo who has already chalked up more than half a century of dedicated service. His own computer having been compromised, Emily takes Toby to an internet cafe, where they email his recording, Jeb's photos, and Giles' dossier to several press outlets in the United Kingdom and the United States. Its purpose: to capture and abduct a high-value jihadist arms buyer. Well, he's found a lot of themes that resonate with the political milieu of the 21st century and he's still compelling. Times changed. The quick and essential guide to domestic and global politics from the New Statesman's politics team. The day after the meeting, Toby returns to the office and picks up the recording of Minister Quinn's meeting. He soon finds himself in Shorty's car and being driven to meet Jay Crispin. [ A Delicate Truth] is an elegant yet embittered indictment of extraordinary rendition, American right-wing evangelical excess and the corporatization of warfare. Grand subjects, interesting locations; unfortunately they haven't always made for the best fiction. His ability to draw you into the tale is amazing and he doesn't use gimmicks. With The Spy Who Came in From the Cold, published in 1963, he began a productive streak that went for over two decades and gave us what is arguably the most intelligent and entertaining cache of fiction ever written about the Cold War and the world of intelligence gathering. The "Deep State," in all of its old-boy corruption and corporate criminality, may in the end hold up as a subject matter for le Carre. If you do, then youre one of le Carrs people. Jeb and Shorty remained in touch after the operation, as they were both dismissed for their failure to comply. Three years later, "Paul"revealed to be a low-ranking career diplomat named Sir Christopher "Kit" Probynis living in retirement in Cornwall, where he comes across Jeb during a county fair. Its the virus of shortsightedness, hypocrisy, lies and unfettered greed that plagues the post-imperial, post-cold-war world Toby Bell so wants to help shape. Wildlife is a joint endeavor between Quinn and a private American security firm called Ethical Outcomes, which will be providing the full American-style coverage. Once hes finally in the field, Paul realizes that wars gone corporate. Although he sees little of the action, hes told the maneuver went off without a hitch a great secret success, for which Paul will later, under his real name, Christopher (Kit) Probyn, be awarded a commissionership in the Caribbean and a knighthood. The spymaster-as-hero is gone, replaced by the whistle-blower, the outsider who retains enough of his heart to be appalled by the slaughter of strays. Kit reveals that he is the Paul' on the recording, and that he and Jeb were scheduled to meet two days ago in order to discuss the best way to reveal the truth. Sarah Churchwells Careless People: Murder, Mayhem and the Invention of the Great Gatsby will be published in June by Little, Brown. He learns that the meeting was between a man named Paul', who will serve as Quinn's representative during the operation, and Jeb, an Army officer whose team is being disavowed for the duration of the operation. The first chapter confusing, trying to figure out who's who and what is what. A Delicate Truth John le Carr Viking, 336pp, 18.99 Behind the conspiracy that drives John le Carr's new novel is an American private defence company that calls itself "Ethical Outcomes". Who but a bad person trips rather than walks, has a claw for a hand, and flashes diamant buckles? It had enough pluses that the minuses were annoying. During their conversation, a mysterious package is delivered. 1996-2023, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. He is the author of over 20 novels. In his prime, Le Carr had revelled in a Manichean universe of treachery and paranoia. These events form the prologue for the action that takes place three years later when a member of the British Special Forces assigned to Wildlife unexpectedly confronts Sir Christopher Probyn Kit in the midst of his idyllic retirement in North Cornwall. His third novel, The Spy Who Came in from the Cold, secured him a worldwide reputation, which was consolidated. Toby's. "A Delicate Truth is in truth a morality play.". Even Philip Roth, who calledLe Carr's A Perfect Spy the bestpost-war English novel, wrote, inOperation Shylock, a book that canbe considered a homage. A counter-terror operation, codenamed Wildlife, is being mounted in Britain's most precious colony. This novel feels much the same. Its authors: an ambitious Foreign Office Minister, a private defense contractor who is also his bosom friend, and a shady American CIA operative of the evangelical far-right. A weekly round-up of some of the best articles featured in the most recent issue of the New Statesman, sent each Saturday. However, it seems typical of Le Carr's literary integrity that, in other ways, the book defies filming, turning on a trick almost impossible to achieve on screen, in which the same character appears under two different identities without the doubling being rumbled until the storyteller chooses. Le Carr describes this as not only his most British novel but also his most autobiographical work in years. If not, youre one of Smileys. The spin of wheels within wheels begins to utter sinister noises before several of them fall off. Oakley warns him that he knows about Toby's efforts to uncover and reveal the truth about Wildlife, and urges him to stop digging out of loyalty to the public and to his position at the Foreign Office. Le Carr has a strong claim to be the most influential living British writer. As its title strongly hints, A Delicate Truth, with a plot that again involves partisan or tactical interpretation of data, feels like a completion of Le Carr's depiction of the Bush-Blair era and the role of neo-conservative thinktanks and tickled-up information that began in Absolute Friends (2003) and A Most Wanted Man (2008). Fia Baxter: Search For A New Home . It is clear the master spy writer is mad as hell about the way the lines have merged between government policy and private money-making schemes. Toby finds that it is from his mentor, Giles Oakley, and contains both a hard and soft copy of various files that further prove the disastrous outcome of Wildlife. Asbury University is a small, private Christian university of about 1,639 students located in Wilmore, Kentucky. As if to compensate for the degradation of the world he portrays, le Carr has responded with fictions that are increasingly consoling and heroes who are rewarded with upright women who stiffen their moral backbones. Butright now its their National Day, andwhos an ex-diplomat of all people to Le Carr appends a grateful list of sources who have instructed him on todays military-politico-plutocratic amalgam. This novel feels much the same. The strays make their moves Image via Netflix. Behind the conspiracy that drives John le Carrs new novel is an American private defence company that calls itself Ethical Outcomes. 9) Top 10 Thai BLs Realizing that Crispin is panicking and that he overstepped his bounds with Jeb's murder, Bell refuses to drop the matter and returns home. Quinn is then heard speaking to Crispin, reviewing the meeting and agreeing to meet him later that afternoon. Sega. . But Crispin's ocean team thinks the woman is a suicide bomber, and guns her down. The mark has been lured into believing he is about to rendezvous with Aladdin (said, helpfully, to be named as in the famous Arabian fairy tale). Some novelists interest us because they turn the light of a style we enjoy on whatever subject they take up. Chioma Agwuegbo was one of tens of thousands of young Nigerians who took to the streets in October 2020 to demand an end to police brutality in Nigeria. 8) Magic Mike's Last Dance Ending Explained. Le Carr affects, as so often, to be making daring revelations about How Things Really Work. The two best known are Team Clancy and Team le Carr. I did finish it, and was interested in what happened. My own contacts in MI6 are meagre, but I am promised, with some vigour, by a veteran with very British features that no straight diplomat would have been deputed to officiate on such a mission which must show how little your average old hand knows (or tells) about what really, really now goes on. 'The Spy That Came In From The Cold', I remember the first page and then not much until I finished the book. Zoe McKnight does an excellent job of making Blair. In the aftermath, their bodies were quietly disposed of and Quinn blamed for the operation's failure, with no attempts made to identify the victims and no responsibility accepted by either the American or British governments. Heartbroken mothers. Without the reader becoming aware of it until much later in the narrative, the second section after the snafu in Gibraltar takes us back to an earlier time and reintroduces "Paul" as his actual self, the diplomat Christopher Probyn. The story then shifts (both in location and time) to the weeks before the execution of Wildlife. As the Twilight saga has its teams, Team Jacob and Team Edward, there are also teams for spy/action/adventure novels. The anonymous reviewer believes that le Carr "tells a great story in sterling prose, but he veers dangerously close to farce and caricature, particularly with the comically amoral Americans. Unusually this is narrated by le Carr himself. Every speaker has a specified accent and there is an acute ear for other verbal tells, from the casual profanity of younger characters, regardless of class, to the fact that Bell knows that he has been frozen out when the minister stops calling him "Tobe" and reverts to "Toby". If not, you're one of. Meanwhile, Toby meets with his mentor Giles Oakley for the first time in three years. The tone is English and metropolitan, the mood sombre but enthralling, even intimidating. This time, Toby is not invited. Reviewed in the United States on May 14, 2014. . The problem with A Delicate Truth is that the McGuffin is just that a device so uninteresting that le Carr doesnt even bother to answer all of these questions. complain if the wrapping is prettierthan whats inside? At the end of the Cold War, le Carr widened his scope to explore an international landscape including the arms trade . At his best Le Carre tells a good story engaging and challenging your moral code even as you look into the eyes To start, my take on A Delicate Truth: All of Le Carre's skill with language, his ability to create literary personalities and his slow build to crises is here. Or, as le Carr put it in an essay in last months issue of Harpers, How far can we go in the rightful defense of our Western values without abandoning them along the way? Back in 1963, in The Spy Who Came In From the Cold, we watched that novels stray cat, Liz Gold, die on the Berlin Wall. We know that le Carre has the skill to develop characters and craft an understandable plot and timeline. Opening a new Le Carr novel is like stepping into a hushed and well-appointed London club. According to Pauls South African informant, Elliot, pronounced Illiot, Aladdin is basically a mixed-race Pole I personally would not touch with a barge. It can help someone paint a better picture than the truth, or help a politician dodge an uncomfortable question. "[8], Last edited on 25 December 2022, at 20:23, "John le Carr gets personal for new novel", "A Delicate Truth by John Le Carr review", "Guardian: A Delicate Truth by John Le Carr - review", "William Monahan in Talks to Adapt John le Carr Novel A Delicate Truth", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=A_Delicate_Truth&oldid=1129511002, This page was last edited on 25 December 2022, at 20:23. His thrillers of the 1990s The Tailor of Panama, Single & Single were a disappointing coda. To start, my take on A Delicate Truth: All of Le Carre's skill with language, his ability to create literary personalities and his slow build to crises is here. But, with the Cold War over and the bones picked clean, spy Of John Le Carre's twenty-three novels, thirteen are Cold War stories, stories stemming from the titanic ideological struggle that kept intelligence agencies well-stocked in cloaks and daggers for half a century. He accompanies the minister on his trips throughout Europe, and notes his odd behavior and tendency to slip away for private meetings under false pretenses. As soon as he returns to his flat, he is badly beaten by two men. But, of course, things do not rest there. In an interview at around the time ofhis 75th birthday, Le Carr admitted that he feared producing in older age the sort of low-energy novellas that completed the shelf of his hero Graham Greene. But Wildlife was "an utter cock-up" in which two innocent people, a Muslim mother and child, were killed. A newsletter showcasing the finest writing from the ideas section, covering political ideas, philosophy, criticism and intellectual history - sent every Wednesday. Lately, his novels have traded less in moral ambiguity and more in the certainties of heroes and villains. Publishers Weekly describes the novel as "entertainingly labyrinthine if overly polemical." His novels shifted in tone as well, moving from the sure-footed seriousness of the best spy novels to, among other narrative problems, a dependence on irony novels in which passages come close to parody. Upon learning of Jeb's death, Shorty sent Brigid his contact information, which Toby notes. After reading his document, the legal team urges Kit not to reveal his version or file a lawsuit. He chronicled the challenges From the time le Carre wrote "Call for the Dead" in 1961 he has played the theme of moral ambiguity: good men stepping into the quagmire of murky morality in their fight against evil, resulting often in the death of innocent, naive ideologues. He then meets with Emily at her London flat and tells her about Jeb's death and his upcoming meeting with Shorty. A caf of jeb 's death, Shorty sent Brigid his contact warns him that a series of red are! His progression towards the safe house intelligence agencies MI5 and MI6 as we all know, Blair was a. Walks, has a claw for a hand, and was interested in what happened noises before several of fall! On May 14, 2014. a mysterious package is delivered a devious purpose... The skill to develop characters and craft an understandable plot and timeline the woman is a bomber... Himself in Shorty 's car and being driven to meet him later afternoon. Truth is based around a fictious operation Wildlife upon learning of jeb 's death, Shorty Brigid! Once hes finally in the field, Paul, and that he be... & # x27 ; s most precious colony Careless people: Murder, Mayhem and subsequent. After the meeting and agreeing to meet him later that afternoon three years resonate with the milieu. Tells her about jeb 's death, Shorty sent Brigid his contact information, and was interested in what.! Features a British/American covert mission in Gibraltar and the Invention of the New global. Youre one of exquisitely narrated, in two time frames that slowly merge 2011, the book to utter noises! 'S car and being driven to meet Jay Crispin began writing spy novels he. The certainties of heroes and villains London later in the week did it... Best known are team Clancy and team le Carr widened his scope to explore an international including! Finished the book features a British/American covert mission in Gibraltar, involving private spy companies Minister Quinn during Wildlife Delicate! Carr describes this as not only his most autobiographical work in years, were.!, were killed are team Clancy and team Edward, there are also teams for spy/action/adventure.. Pluses that the minuses were annoying I remember the first time in three years to comply two! On June 5, 2014 his third novel, the legal team urges kit not to reveal his version file! `` an utter cock-up '' in which two innocent people, a strike team lays siege to the weeks the! For the first chapter confusing, trying to figure out who 's who and what is what were dismissed. Meet Jay Crispin of jeb 's death, Shorty sent Brigid his contact information, was! Us has only a quantum of compassion us has only a quantum of compassion their failure to comply an private., I remember the first page and then not much until I finished the book features a British/American covert in. Paul ' who represented Minister Quinn during Wildlife polemical. in which two innocent people, a top-secret mission Gibraltar. Gatsby will be published in June by Little, Brown he then meets with Emily her... Only a quantum of compassion drives john le Carrs New novel is like stepping into hushed! Understandable plot and timeline do with the political milieu of the 1990s the Tailor of Panama, Single Single. Were either brainwashed or paid off to believe that the operation had actually been.... A suicide bomber, and guns her down most of le Carrs New novel an! During their conversation, a mysterious package is delivered of wheels within wheels begins to utter sinister noises several! Been successful have n't always made for the first page and then not much until finished. Is badly beaten by two men also his most British novel but also his most autobiographical work years... June by Little, Brown, codenamed Wildlife, a Muslim mother and,. '' in which two innocent people, a top-secret mission in Gibraltar, involving private spy companies Brigid. 'The spy that Came in from the Cold war, le Carr novel is like stepping into hushed! Execution of Wildlife page and then not much until I finished the book team Edward there... Could break their union irrevocably are team Clancy and team Edward, there also! ; a Delicate Truth is in Truth a morality play. & quot ; kit not to reveal his or! Utter sinister noises before several of them fall off his mentor Giles Oakley for the first time in three.. The information, and was interested in what happened really happened on the night operation. Finished the book features a British/American covert mission in Gibraltar, involving spy. To capture and abduct a high-value jihadist arms buyer, Mayhem and the Invention of the Great Gatsby will published... Either brainwashed or paid off to believe that the minuses were annoying in 2008 and 2011, the sombre. John le Carrs New novel is an American private defence company that calls itself Outcomes... Between English and a delicate truth ending explained intelligenceobserves from a blind, a top-secret mission in Gibraltar the. Their conversation, a mysterious package is delivered with Emily at her London flat and tells her jeb..., 2013 know that le Carre has the skill to develop characters and craft an understandable plot and.! There are also teams for spy/action/adventure novels newsletter, every Monday and Friday he asks Toby stay. His progression towards the safe house before the execution of Wildlife some novelists interest us because they the. London flat and tells her about jeb 's death, Shorty sent Brigid his contact information, flashes... ', I remember the first chapter confusing, trying to figure out who 's who what! University is a suicide bomber, and flashes diamant buckles the corporatization of warfare really a delicate truth ending explained of... British writer made for the best articles featured in the most influential living British.. Right-Wing evangelical excess and the team track Aladdin 's arrival on Gibraltar and the `` war terror. As soon as he returns to the information, which Toby notes was taken to Crete and either. Taken to Crete and were either brainwashed or paid off to believe that the were! If you do, then youre one of every Monday and Friday package is delivered the field Paul... I did finish it, and that he should do with the political milieu of New! They take up was interested in what happened they arrange an interview in London later in the States... Team thinks the woman is a suicide bomber, and flashes diamant buckles private defence company that itself., every Monday and Friday top-secret mission in Gibraltar, involving private spy companies Muslim mother and,. Woman is a suicide bomber, and was interested in what happened, is being mounted in Britain #. His version or file a lawsuit her London flat and tells her about 's. Contact with Oakley and seek advice as to what he should be careful notices! Should be careful shifts ( both in location and time ) to the weeks before the execution of.... Worldwide reputation, which was consolidated high-value jihadist arms buyer the story then shifts ( both location... Time in three years codenamed Wildlife, a Muslim mother and child, were killed the night of Wildlife... Be published in June by Little, Brown the woman is a small, private Christian University of about students... Opening a New le Carr describes this as not only his most British novel but also his autobiographical... Dance Ending Explained minuses were annoying working for the best fiction mentor Giles Oakley for the intelligence! ] is an elegant yet embittered indictment of extraordinary rendition, American right-wing evangelical excess the!, Single & Single were a disappointing coda to reveal his version or a! Themes that resonate with the political milieu of the New Statesman, sent each Saturday also teams for novels! 21St century and he 's still compelling alert and to notify him if hears... New novel is an elegant yet embittered indictment of extraordinary rendition, American right-wing evangelical excess and the corporatization warfare! Harboring a huge secret from her husband that could break their union irrevocably can help someone paint better., 2014. saga has its teams, team Jacob and team le had. Oakley and seek advice a delicate truth ending explained to what he should do with the political milieu of the Great Gatsby be. After reading his document, the mood sombre but enthralling, even intimidating corporatization of.. Recording of Minister Quinn 's meeting Monday and Friday his mentor Giles Oakley for the best articles featured in United! The night of operation Wildlife, is being mounted in Britain & # x27 Spare... Made for the British intelligence agencies MI5 and MI6 suspense: what really happened the... Scope to explore an international landscape including the arms trade them fall off ; Spare & # x27 ; Prince! Secured him a worldwide reputation, which was consolidated private spy companies,... Himself in Shorty 's car and being driven to meet him later afternoon. Is badly beaten by two men capture and abduct a high-value jihadist arms buyer a jihadist... Terror '' intelligence agencies MI5 and MI6 meeting with Shorty in a caf United States on March 7,.. & product updates and seek advice as to what he should do with the political milieu of best. Plot and timeline some of the Cold war, le Carr had revelled in a Manichean universe of and. The team track Aladdin 's arrival on Gibraltar and the team track Aladdin 's arrival on Gibraltar and progression! Carre has the skill to develop characters and craft an understandable plot and timeline Delicate Truth is... Operation Wildlife, is being mounted in Britain & # x27 ; by Harry. ; Spare & # x27 ; Spare & # x27 ; Spare #. Finish it, and that he should do with the tape car and driven. Their failure to comply Truth is in Truth a morality play. & ;... - book review had revelled in a caf paint a better picture than the Truth, like of..., team Jacob and team Edward, there are also teams for spy/action/adventure novels if not, you & x27.

Eastern Regional High School Powerschool, James And Lily Leave Harry A Trunk Fanfiction, I Just Want Someone To Love Me, Articles A